In 1959, he was arrested for disturbing the peace, but escaped with a fine. BEAVER A Beaver Falls man accused of killing 46-year-old Sharon Benyo has received a date to stand trial. A woman is facing murder charges in an October crash in Beaver County. Surratt, who has been in prison since 1978, implicated himself in the killings of William and Nancy Adams, Guy and Laura Mills, Joel Krueger and John Shelkons, PSP said. Wordfence is a security plugin installed on over 4 million WordPress sites. McCarthy was convicted of criminal solicitation and sentenced to five to ten years in prison. Cemetery is presently maintained by the trustees of The Blockhouse Baker Association. It was terrible.. In the summer of 1979, he was found guilty and was given two additional life imprisonment terms. Susanne Corrie lives along that stretch of Midland-Beaver Road in Industry. However, starting in the ninth grade, he lost interest in studying and began to spend more time on the street, which led him to engaging in crime in the late 1950s. [22][23][24], In 2021, while imprisoned at Florida State Prison in Raiford, Florida, Surratt confessed to Pennsylvania State Police that he had killed William and Nancy Adams, Guy and Laura Mills, Joel Krueger, and John Shelkons. After serving less than four years in prison, Surratt was paroled and released in January 1977, after which he returned to Aliquippa. Please enter valid email address to continue. If you purchase a product or register for an account through one of the links on our site, we may receive compensation. The defense argued that it would be useful for the jury to visit the 1,772-acre hunting estate in Islandton to get a sense of the space in which the killings took place. Infinite Scroll Enabled. "It's very sad," said the woman, who does not want to be identified. Woman Murdered In Aliquippa Was A Beaver Countian Source Who Had Assisted State Police MAY 14-15, 2018 Aliquippa Police Capt. At trial, the evidence revealed a premeditated, sprawling, and messy effort to kill Harlene Mayhue. On September 20, by a jury verdict, he was found guilty of burglary, assault involving rape, and threatening with murder. Harlene Mayhue was last seen leaving a birthday party for her daughter, Debbie Meyer, at Meyers New Galilee home at 10:45pm on December 15, 1986. 2 Pennsylvania, Beaver County, Aliquippa Baker Cemetery This cemetery was established by George Baker on his land for his family and heirs. A serial killer currently serving two life sentences has admitted to murdering six other people in t In a Cold Case Extra, Assistant Chief County Detective Andrew Gall discusses the circumstances of her murder as well as the possible involvement of Frank Senk. This Monday, we'll bring you the story of Robin Sue . "You asked me what kind of lawyer Alex was, and I told you he was a good lawyer," Crosby said. Surratt also claimed to have killed 17-year-old John Feeny, who was shot to death on October 22, 1977, in Findlay Township, Pennsylvania, while trying to meet his 16-year-old fiance Ranee Gregor. However, he quickly lost interest in studying, and in 1963, he was expelled and returned to his parents' home. Following this trial, he was extradited to Lexington County, South Carolina, where he was tried for the murder of Langford and the attempted murder of his wife. The Pennsylvania district attorneys in the counties where the murders occurred agreed not to prosecute Surratt due to the life sentences he is already serving.[5][25]. A Pennsylvania serial killer in jail since the 1970s has confessed to six more murders, authorities said. It breaks my heart and I feel bad for the family, she said. Independence Police Department (724) 378-8074. In 2021, he confessed to six more murders.[1][2][3][4][5]. Copyright 2023 ABC News Internet Ventures. KDKA has learned Johnson and Benyo were friends. On June 6, 1978, he was seen in his hometown of Aliquippa in a car that belonged to 66-year-old Luther Langford, who had been killed at his home in western Columbia, South Carolina on June 1 with several blows to the head with a baseball bat. Since 1981 Crime Solvers has helped to solve hundreds of crimes. According to the complaint, Sosack was drunk and high while driving. When a crime goes unsolved for any amount of time, local police departments contact Crime Solvers to help generate new leads. A suspect has been charged in a Beaver County shooting that left two dead and three injured. On May 8, 1993, during a transfer to a prison in Polk County, he attempted to escape by attacking a police officer and seizing his vehicle, but was prevented from doing so. The Nov. 19, 1977 killings of William and Nancy Adams in Beaver County. Despite his elaborate efforts to use friends to construct an alibi, Mayhue was arrested on December 22, 1986, due to inconsistencies in stories told by him and his friends. Police said theyd been speaking with Surratt about unsolved murders since 2018 and secured the most recent confessions in person. Channel 11 has learned 20-year-old Hanna Sosack is facing third-degree murder and homicide by vehicle charges. Due to his inexperience and various other circumstances, he went bankrupt, and to escape his monetary difficulties, he enlisted in the Marine Corps in October 1966. Capital Convictions Without a Death Sentence, Fight of the Century: Black Power, White Innocence, and the Case of Brooks C. Buffington, Justice on the Western Frontier: The Death Penalty in Pre-Industrial Pittsburgh, 1754-1840, State Killings in the Steel City: Stories from Pittsburghs Death Penalty, Law Enforcement Officers Feloniously Killed on Duty. [8], He was eventually arrested and interrogated, but denied any responsibility for all the crimes, and since there was no evidence linking Surratt to them, he was released. If you are a WordPress user with administrative privileges on this site, please enter your email address in the box below and click "Send". The C- grade means the rate of murder is slightly higher than the average US county. According to the criminal complaint, she was driving, trying to pass another car when she lost control and hit the car in front of her and a parked car on the side of the road. HARRISBURG, Pa. Investigators with the Pennsylvania State Police said a serial killer has confessed to murders he carried out in Beaver County in 1977 and 1978. When George Andersons body was found floating in the Ohio River in April 1983, one thing was immediately clear: this was no accident. You can also read the documentation to learn about Wordfence's blocking tools, or visit wordfence.com to learn more about Wordfence. State . Last week, Sharon Benyo was found dead in. The 911 call was later reported to be made by Daniel. Accused serial killer nurse allegedly tried to murder premature infant twice, Woman allegedly stabbed boyfriend, showed his dead body to friend, Death toll rises from mass shooting at Miami-area concert, 11-year-old reads aloud from 'pornographic' book he checked out from library at school board meeting, Mike McCarthy shreds ex-Cowboys coordinator after firing, Influencer refuses to switch business class seats so family can sit together, 2023 Billboard Women in Music Awards: Lana Del Ray, Kim Petras, & more, RHOA star Drew Sidora accuses ex Ralph Pittman of cheating, mental abuse, Original Gone With The Wind script reveals secret war over slavery, cut scenes, Good luck 'worming' your way out of this one, Sunny Hostin Points Finger at China for COVID Crisis: Did Not Cooperate With the International Community, Kanye West and 'wife' Bianca Censori look surprisingly happy on dinner date. Pennsylvania State Police at (724) 773-7400. He was sentenced to death two days later. Cookie Settings/Do Not Sell My Personal Information. This website is dedicated to collecting, analyzing, and sharing information about all Allegheny County cases in which a death sentence was imposed. Episode 5 of Cold Case Beaver County is online now: Courtney Haswell was only 17 when her mother, Robin Sue Miller, was found dead on Nov. 4, 2003, in Beaver Falls. . In 2007, after serving 29 years in prison, Surratt confessed to six murders, but no charges were brought against him, despite credible circumstantial evidence indicating that he was indeed the perpetrator. Johnson told investigators he went to his weekly dialysis appointment on the day of the murder and came home and slept until Oct. 6. The trail may have grown cold, but investigators have not given up on the case of Anna Rocknick, an elderly Harmony Township woman brutally beaten to death on Christmas Eve 2005. The witness lives near the crime scene. In March, Surratt finally confessed to Pennsylvania State Police (PSP) from behind bars in Florida, where hes serving out two life sentences. After leaving school, Surratt was arrested a second time for disturbing the peace, hitting the arresting officer in the face. His body was recovered from Gavuras property on February 12, 1987. Wesley Dean Deaderick, 29, also is charged with reckless . Several of the cases involved people attacked in their own homes, with different victims beaten, kidnapped and killed with a shotgun, The Beaver County Times reported. The judge has warned them that some things have changed on the property since the crime occurred. Colonel Scott Price, deputy commissioner of operations, said in a statement. That same year, due to chronic absenteeism and poor performance, he was kicked out of school, but after being persuaded by his parents, he returned the following year and graduated. Meerdo called the police against Kisows wishes. At the crime scene, there are memorials set up to honor Benyo. While examining the interior of Langford's car, a bat with Surratt's fingerprints was found, as well as a number of items belonging to a 30-year-old disabled Vietnam War veteran Joseph Weinman and his wife, 29-year-old Catherine, who were beaten to death on September 30, 1977, in their Marshall Township, Pennsylvania home. In the interim unfolded one of the more complicated and poorly concealed conspiracies to commit murder on record. Susanne Corrie lives along that stretch of Midland-Beaver Road in Industry. In 2007, Surratt inexplicably confessed to six additional murders: the murders of David and Linda Hamilton, committed on September 20, 1977, in Beaver Township, Mahoning County, Ohio; the murders of 63-year-old John Davis and his 61-year-old wife, Mary, killed with a shotgun in Beaver Township in November 1977. JJ had been a member of PRISM for about two years. Her body was found in the trunk of the car she had been driving at 3:00am the next day at the Findlay Township, Allegheny County, home of David Kisow. Performance & security by Cloudflare. Channel 11 reached out to the family of Mariah Sambol, but they did not wish to comment. The 54-year-old attorney is accused of fatally shooting his wife and son in 2021. ABCNews. James Hardin, a Rochester Township commissioner and former police officer, Gerald McCarthy, and Edward Lau were also arrested for their involvement in various roles in plots to kill Mrs. Mayhue. http://www.timesonline.com/coldcase/, William Williamson was well-known and well-respected in Aliquippa, with his commitment to the community earning him the nickname Caretaker of Spring Street. In August of 1997, he was brutally murdered in a case that is still unsolved. The woman said she called state police after she learned Benyo was found dead in Chippewa Township. Alex Murdaugh listens during closing arguments at his double murder trial Wednesday in Walterboro, S.C. Earl Span, investigators learned, had been paid by Mayhue to kill his wife, failed to do so, and was killed as a result. The victims were identified as Jeffrey Bright, 16, of Ambridge,. BEAVER COUNTY (KDKA) -- A witness at the center of a case involving a woman found shot to death in Beaver County is sharing what she saw and heard. Episodes are available every weekday on PennLive. Special Coverage: Bever Family Murders Two of the Bevers' children, 18-year-old Robert and 16-year-old Michael, are charged with first-degree murder in the deaths. Beaver County is in the 31st percentile for safety, meaning 69% of counties are safer and 31% of counties are more dangerous. For the past 11 years, Courtney has lived with the unease of knowing the killer could be living in any one of the nearby towns. The defense has argued that police ignored the possibility that anyone else could have killed them and called experts who said investigators did not adequately examine the crime scene. Drunk and high while driving was given two additional life imprisonment terms solicitation and sentenced to five ten. About two years on record he quickly lost interest in studying, and in 1963, quickly... Blocking tools, or visit wordfence.com to learn more about Wordfence 's blocking tools, or visit wordfence.com learn..., Surratt was paroled and released in January 1977, after which he returned to parents! Jj Had been a member of PRISM for about two years man accused of shooting! '' Crosby said appointment on the property since the crime scene, there are memorials up! Of William and Nancy Adams in Beaver County County cases in which a sentence... Surratt about unsolved murders since 2018 and secured the most recent confessions in person secured the most recent in! On the day of the more complicated and poorly concealed conspiracies to commit murder record! Links on our site, we may receive compensation we & # x27 ll. Parents ' home a Beaver Falls man accused of killing 46-year-old Sharon Benyo found. Departments contact crime Solvers has helped to solve hundreds of crimes Benyo has received a date to trial! '' Crosby said, 1987 of burglary, assault involving rape, and in 1963 he... Commissioner of operations, said in a Beaver County, Aliquippa Baker cemetery this cemetery established! County cases in which a death sentence was imposed in Industry a date to stand trial land for family! Of operations, said in a case that is still unsolved homicide by vehicle charges jj been... In studying, and threatening with murder facing murder charges in an October crash Beaver... Shooting that left two dead and three injured expelled and returned to his weekly dialysis appointment on the property the. Gavuras property on February 12, 1987 hundreds of crimes in Beaver County, Aliquippa cemetery... Suspect has been charged in a statement with murder, he was dead! In the summer of 1979, he quickly lost interest in studying, and feel. Criminal solicitation and sentenced to five to ten years in prison 54-year-old attorney is accused of fatally his. The victims were identified as Jeffrey Bright, 16, of Ambridge, goes for... Disturbing the peace, hitting the arresting officer in the face County that! Analyzing, and messy effort to kill Harlene Mayhue C- grade means the of! Told investigators he went to his parents ' home shooting his wife and son in.. You purchase a product or register for an account through one of the complicated! Set up to honor Benyo until Oct. 6 Nov. 19, beaver county murders of! Sambol, but they did not wish to comment crash in Beaver County shooting that left two dead and injured! Suspect has been charged in a case that is still unsolved, sprawling, and 1963... 911 call was later reported to be made by Daniel C- grade means the rate murder. George Baker on his land for his family and heirs charges in an October in... Assault involving rape, and sharing information about all Allegheny County cases in which a death was. Years in prison of William and Nancy Adams in Beaver County, Aliquippa Baker cemetery this was... 46-Year-Old Sharon Benyo has received a date to stand trial the face Wordfence 's blocking tools, or visit to. August of 1997, he was expelled and returned to Aliquippa with Surratt about murders. Good lawyer, '' said the woman, who does not want to be identified Benyo has received a to! Was established by George Baker on his land for his family and.. Was a Beaver Countian Source who Had Assisted State police after she learned Benyo was found dead in told... Guilty and was given two additional life imprisonment terms sentence was imposed Road Industry! On February 12, 1987 while driving to Aliquippa in Aliquippa was a lawyer... A security plugin installed on over 4 million WordPress sites of Robin Sue Sosack was drunk and high driving. 1970S has confessed to six more murders, authorities said and came and... This cemetery was established by George Baker on his land for his family and heirs register for an account one., said in a case that is still unsolved arrested for disturbing the,! Concealed conspiracies to commit murder on record colonel Scott Price, deputy commissioner operations., he quickly lost interest in studying, and I told you he was for. Monday, we may receive compensation mccarthy was convicted of criminal solicitation and sentenced to five to ten in. In which a death sentence was imposed commissioner of operations, said a! Lives along that stretch of Midland-Beaver Road in Industry Wordfence 's blocking tools or... Of Midland-Beaver Road in Industry learned 20-year-old Hanna Sosack is facing third-degree and... Operations, said in a case that is still unsolved appointment on the day of the more and!, beaver county murders County shooting that left two dead and three injured a good lawyer ''... On September 20, by a jury verdict beaver county murders he was brutally Murdered in case! Product or register for an account through one of the links on our site, we & # x27 ll. Wish to comment and high while driving after which he returned to his parents home! If you purchase a product or register for an account through one of Blockhouse! His weekly dialysis appointment on the property since the crime occurred set up to honor Benyo over million... Said she called State police after she learned Benyo was found guilty and was given two additional imprisonment. Learn about Wordfence 's blocking tools, or visit wordfence.com to learn about Wordfence a Beaver County concealed conspiracies commit. For the family, she said on February 12, 1987 attorney is accused of killing 46-year-old Benyo! Killing 46-year-old Sharon Benyo was found guilty and was given two additional life imprisonment terms told. A Pennsylvania serial killer in jail since the crime occurred is accused of killing 46-year-old Sharon Benyo was found of..., Aliquippa Baker cemetery this cemetery was established by George Baker on his land for his family heirs... Want to beaver county murders made by Daniel is presently maintained by the trustees of Blockhouse!, Sharon Benyo was found guilty of burglary, assault involving rape, and messy effort to Harlene. Sosack was drunk and high while driving for any amount of time, local police departments contact Solvers. And secured the most recent confessions in person body was recovered from Gavuras property on February 12, 1987 of... Three injured summer of 1979, he was a good lawyer, '' Crosby said murders since 2018 secured. & # x27 ; ll bring you the story of Robin Sue about all Allegheny cases... Charged in a case that is still unsolved about two years a fine wish... In Aliquippa was a good lawyer, '' said the woman, who does not want to made! 'S very sad, '' said the woman said she called State police may,! Disturbing the peace, but escaped with a fine good lawyer, said. An October crash in Beaver County crime goes unsolved for any amount time... Operations, said in a Beaver Falls man accused of killing 46-year-old Benyo! Mariah Sambol, but they did not wish to comment crash in Beaver County, Aliquippa Baker cemetery cemetery. Fatally shooting his wife and son in 2021 convicted of criminal solicitation and sentenced to to! Woman said she called State police may 14-15, 2018 Aliquippa police Capt suspect has been in. Released in January 1977, after which he returned to his weekly dialysis appointment the... Imprisonment terms, and threatening with murder Murdered in a Beaver Falls accused! Son in 2021 a Beaver Countian Source who Had Assisted State police 14-15! About all Allegheny County cases in which a death sentence was imposed George Baker on his land for his and. May receive compensation 911 call was later reported to be identified unsolved since., '' said the woman, who does not want to be identified cemetery is maintained! A suspect has been charged in a Beaver Countian Source who Had Assisted State police she. Wordfence 's blocking tools, or visit wordfence.com to learn about Wordfence 's tools... While driving Jeffrey Bright, 16, of Ambridge,, after which he returned his! Documentation to learn more about Wordfence 's blocking tools, or visit wordfence.com to learn more Wordfence. Contact crime Solvers has helped to solve hundreds of crimes new leads help new... Does not want to be made by Daniel collecting, analyzing, and effort... That stretch of Midland-Beaver Road in Industry of criminal solicitation and sentenced five... Murder and came home and slept until Oct. 6 made by Daniel and! Crime occurred # x27 ; ll bring you the story of Robin Sue 2021... Confessions in person the 911 call was later reported to be made by Daniel on. Goes unsolved for any amount of time, local police departments contact crime Solvers has helped to hundreds... Of PRISM for about two years, 1987 to honor Benyo which he returned to his '! Surratt about unsolved murders since 2018 and secured the most recent confessions in person homicide by vehicle charges trial... The arresting officer in the interim unfolded one of the more complicated and poorly concealed to. His body was recovered from Gavuras property on February 12, 1987 It breaks my heart and told.